Mapping Judicial Dialogue across National Borders : An Exploratory Network Study of Learning from Lobbying among European Intellectual Property Judges
Lazega, Emmanuel (2012), Mapping Judicial Dialogue across National Borders : An Exploratory Network Study of Learning from Lobbying among European Intellectual Property Judges, Utrecht Law Review, 8, 2, p. 115-128
TypeArticle accepté pour publication ou publié
Journal nameUtrecht Law Review
MetadataShow full item record
Abstract (EN)This paper looks at dialogue and collective learning across borders through personal networks of judges. We focus on judges participating in the Venice Forum, bringing together European patent judges involved in institutional lobbying for the construction of a European Patent Court. Empirical observation shows that personal networks of discussion with foreign judges, reading of their work and references to their decisions do exist in this milieu and can be mapped. Our network study shows that judges from some European countries are more active in this dialogue than judges from other countries. The learning process is driven, to some extent, by a small subset of super-central judges who frame this dialogue and can be considered to be opinion leaders in this social milieu. We measure a strong level of consensus among the judges on several controversial issues surrounding the procedure of a possible future European Patent Court. But strong differences between them remain. Dialogue and collective learning do not, by themselves, lead to convergence towards a uniform position in these controversies.
Subjects / Keywordslobbying; citation networks; reading networks; discussion networks; collective learning; European patent judges
Showing items related by title and author.
A spinning top model of formal organization and informal behaviour: Dynamics of advice networks among judges in a commercial court Mounier, Lise; Lemercier, Claire; Lazega, Emmanuel (2006) Article accepté pour publication ou publié
Norms, Advice Networks and Joint Economic Governance : The Case of Conflicts among Shareholders at the Commercial Court of Paris Tubaro, Paola; Mounier, Lise; Lazega, Emmanuel (2011) Chapitre d'ouvrage