An Historically-Grounded Critical Analysis of Research Articles in IS
de Vaujany, François-Xavier; Mitev, Nathalie; Walsh, Isabelle (2011), An Historically-Grounded Critical Analysis of Research Articles in IS, European Journal of Information Systems, 20, 4, p. 395-417. http://dx.doi.org/10.1057/ejis.2011.13
TypeArticle accepté pour publication ou publié
Journal nameEuropean Journal of Information Systems
MetadataShow full item record
Author(s)de Vaujany, François-Xavier
Dauphine Recherches en Management [DRM]
Department of Management - London School of Economics and Political Science [LSE]
Abstract (EN)In order to explore scientific writing in Information Systems (IS) journals, we adopt a combination of historical and rhetorical approaches. We first investigate the history of universities, business schools, learned societies and scientific articles. This perspective allows us to capture the legacy of scientific writing standards, which emerged in the 18th and 19th centuries. Then, we focus on two leading IS journals (EJIS and MISQ). An historical analysis of both outlets is carried out, based on data related to their creation, evolution of editorial statements, and key epistemological and methodological aspects. We also focus on argumentative strategies found in a sample of 436 abstracts from both journals. Three main logical anchorages (sometimes combined) are identified, and related to three argumentative strategies: 'deepening of knowledge', 'solving an enigma' and 'addressing a practical managerial issue'. We relate these writing norms to historical imprints of management and business studies, in particular: enigmafocused rhetorics, interest in institutionalized literature, neglect for managerially grounded rhetoric and lack of reflexivity in scientific writing. We explain this relation as a quest for academic legitimacy. Lastly, some suggestions are offered to address the discrepancies between these writing norms and more recent epistemological and theoretical stances adopted by IS researchers.
Subjects / KeywordsResearch Articles; History of Scientific Articles; Argumentative Strategies; MISQ; Academic Writing; Academic Legitimacy; EJIS
Showing items related by title and author.
Developing theoretical contributions in IS research: a focus on revision processes in top-tier journals Organizations de Vaujany, François-Xavier; Mitev, Nathalie; Walsh, Isabelle (2011) Communication / Conférence
Applying and theorizing institutional frameworks in IS research: a systematic comparison from 1999 to 2009 Carton, Sabine; de Vaujany, François-Xavier; Mitev, Nathalie; Romeyer, Cécile (2014) Article accepté pour publication ou publié
Introduction: Time and Materiality: What Is at Stake in the Materialization of Time and Time as a Materialization? de Vaujany, François-Xavier; Laniray, Pierre; Mitev, Nathalie; Vaast, Emmanuelle (2014) Chapitre d'ouvrage