Comment: Inferring Trade Costs from Trade Booms and Trade Busts
Corlay, Guillaume; Dupraz, Stéphane; Labonne, Claire; Muller, Anne; Antonin, Céline; Daudin, Guillaume (2016), Comment: Inferring Trade Costs from Trade Booms and Trade Busts. https://basepub.dauphine.fr/handle/123456789/16274
TypeDocument de travail / Working paper
Series titleWP Centre d'Economie de l'université Paris-Nord
MetadataShow full item record
Abstract (EN)Jacks et al. (2011) offer an alternative to price gaps to quantify trade costs. Implementing a method which consists in deducing international trade costs from trade flows, they argue that the reduction in trade costs was the main driving force of trade growth during the first globalization (1870-1913), whereas economic expansion was the main driving force during the second globalization (1950-2000). We argue that this important result is driven by the use of an ad hoc aggregation method. What Jacks et al. (2011) capture is the difference in the relative starting trade of dyads experiencing faster trade growth in the first and second globalization. More generally, we cast doubts on the possibility to reach conclusions of such nature with a method that infers trade costs from trade flows, and then uses these costs to explain trade flows. We argue that it can only rephrase the information already contained in openness ratios.
Subjects / KeywordsTrade costs; globalization; gravity model; aggregation; structure effect; F14; N70
Showing items related by title and author.
Corlay, Guillaume; Dupraz, Stéphane; Labonne, Claire; Muller, Anne; Antonin, Céline; Daudin, Guillaume (2017) Article accepté pour publication ou publié
Exploring the Transformation of French and European Trade and Economy in the Long Eighteenth Century (1713-1823) : the TOFLIT18 Project Charles, Loïc; Daudin, Guillaume; Girard, Paul; Plique, Guillaume (2022-04) Article accepté pour publication ou publié